“Waitress” embraces its comedic nature, and every actor gets their fair share of witty material to play with. Perhaps the most successful among them was Jacob Tischler, who plays Ogie, an earnest tax auditor Dawn met on a dating app who drives a subcompact Toyota Yaris and adores his mother. His performance in a particularly earnest scene at the diner was an obvious highlight."​
​
-Valley News
"Jacob Tischler plays Dawn's suitor Ogie, a scene-stealing role if there ever was one. Tischler goes beyond riotous physical stunts to give the character undeniable joy."
​
-Seven Days
"It speaks to the actor’s committed performance as Hollywood musician Cosmo Brown that the standout number in the Olney Theatre Center production is not the title song...but rather Cosmo’s tour de force tune, “Make ’Em Laugh.” It’s a lung-bursting display of sheer vaudevillian prowess."
​
-The Washington Post
"Tischler captures the outlandishly acrobatic joie de vivre of “Make ‘Em Laugh” without hurting himself"
​
-MetroWeekly
"Jacob Scott Tischler performs one show-stealer after another. Making his OTC debut, he threw his body all over the stage in “Make ‘Em Laugh” and wowed us in “Moses Supposes.” I bet Donald O’Connor would have approved of this talented triple threat."
​
-DC Metro Theatre Arts
"Tischler captures the second banana role and is nothing short of terrific in his big number, “Make ‘Em Laugh.”
​
-MD Theatre Guide
"Tischler’s four years with Vermont-based youth circus Circus Smirkus shows in his remarkable physical nimbleness. Watch him, for example, in “Fascinatin’ Rhythm” trying to fight off some unknown rhythm, or rhythms, that are determined to possess him."
​
-Berkshire Eagle
"There is some elaborate and entertaining dancing choreographed by Jeffrey L. Page, most notably performed by Jacob Tischler. Tischler also provides much of the comedic moments; often seeming to be an amalgamation of Jerry Lewis, Nathan Lane, and Sean Hayes."
​
-Broadway World
"Tischler and Umphress offered up 'Let’s Call the Whole Thing Off' (from "Shall We Dance") with ditzy charm."
​
-Rural Intelligence
"Jacob Tischler as Tony Manero played the role with heart and sang with impressive vocals. He was not merely a John Travolta impersonator. The dancing was acrobatic but Mr. Tischler was effortless in his execution."
​
"At no point is there a feeling that Tischler’s Tony Manero is a caricature or a cheap impersonation of Travolta. He truly does make the character a unique representation."
​
​
"Jacob Tischler did an excellent job as Tony. He made the part his own and his talent was evident whether acting, energetic dancing, or singing. He conveyed Tony’s emotions with animated body language, facial expressions, and tone and just oozed attitude. His performance of “Tragedy” was outstanding."
​
"Jacob Tischler is a youthful ball of energy. He springs to his feet and leaps over obstacles; even quicksand seems no match for him. Tischler's earnest grin encourages us to root for him."
​
​
"As Sir Henry Baskerville and several other characters, Tischler is, by turns, charming, clueless and love struck."
​
"Tischler deserves serious recognition as the comic relief who delivered each joke and punch line flawlessly. The audience laughed each time they were predictably supposed to, and were rooting for Jimmy and Gloria's love story."
​
"Jacob Tischler has a surpisingly stunning voice for a secondary character."​
​